Propriety and passion:
Which is more important in a person’s life?
E. D. Forster’s novel A room with a view presents the battle between what is established by society of how a person should be and act and the pursuing of personal passions and dreams even if you are against the rules of society. James Ivory’s film based in the mentioned novel is a close adaptation of the novel: that even divide the movie into chapter with the same names as the novel. Two big themes are present in the plot of the novel as well in the film: propriety and passion both themes are the axis of the novel.
Lucy Honeychurch the main character of the novel is open to a new world different that the one she used to lived when she and Miss Charlotte travel to
When Lucy returns to her home to Britain Cecil propose marriage to her. Lucy accept the proposition because is the proper thing to do for a lady when a man of high social status propose marriage. And that’s the dream of every mother that her daughter marry a man with good propriety, sophisticated and with a high social status. Cecil sees Lucy as a material gain a commodity unlike George that he really loves Lucy and treat her as a companion.
In the film we can see the mentioned comparison between Cecil and George in many scenes for example: the scene where George, and others are playing tennis, Lucy invite George to play and he decline the offer and said he prefer his book. And what about the scenes of George kissing Lucy and Cecil kissing Lucy; you can see that George and Cecil are completely opposite persons Cecil lacks the passion and desire to live that George has. The film show all the procedure that Cecil make to kiss Lucy on the other part George just go for it he didn’t ask permission. If Lucy marries Cecil he would have made Lucy’s life unhappy. The only way Lucy took out all her frustrations was when she was playing piano, even the song that Lucy plays are expressive showing the passionate side of Lucy playing Beethoven.
The film did a great representation of the values, personal appearance of the characters; settings were beautiful displaying what Cecil is missing and the cast of actors. And specifically the way Lucy interacts with the significant characters to shape to what she learns from the others.